Drag
Silky Nutmeg Ganache Under Fire for Racist Reading Challenge
Silky tried to read Plastique Tiara, a Vietnamese queen, by speaking Japanese.
April 26 2019 3:35 PM EST
May 26 2023 1:44 PM EST
By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use.
Silky tried to read Plastique Tiara, a Vietnamese queen, by speaking Japanese.
The library opened -- and people would like it to close.
On Thursday night's episode of RuPaul's Drag Race, during the infamous reading mini challenge, Silky Nutmeg Ganache stepped up to the plate to read fellow contestant Plastique Tiara. During her series of rhyming (and mostly unfunny) reads, Silky's statements to Plastique included speaking in attempted Japanese, something that some fans -- and fellow Drag Race queens -- have taken issue with.
During the challenge, Silky repeated the words "Hayaku! Hayaku!" to Plastique, which she said meant "Hurry up!" though the translation is up for debate.
\u201cracism against asians is so normalized that this shit often goes unnoticed https://t.co/2xiOVLOFNB\u201d— \ud835\udc1a\ud835\udc2f\ud835\udc1e\ud835\udc25\ud835\udc32\ud835\udc27 (@\ud835\udc1a\ud835\udc2f\ud835\udc1e\ud835\udc25\ud835\udc32\ud835\udc27) 1556133021
"What the fuck does that mean?" Plastique responded, looking confused. Silky offered a translation, to which Plastique responded: "I'm not Japanese!"
Season 11 contestant Soju tweeted after last night's episode, "I'm Korean and Plastique is Vietnamese." When a fan quote tweeted her and told her to mention Silky in the tweet, she responded that this was not about calling Silky out, that it was about education.
"I know your heritage. But what puzzles me is that reads that rhymes which I did to every girl has become I'm racist. Okay. Y'all can play into that if you want," Silky wrote on Twitter.
\u201c@shotwithsoju I know your heritage. But what puzzles me is that reads that rhymes which I did to every girl has become I\u2019m racist. Okay. Y\u2019all can play into that if you want.\u201d— Silky \u201cCancel Student Loans\u201d Ganache (@Silky \u201cCancel Student Loans\u201d Ganache) 1556188157
"You're not a racist," Soju responded, drawing a distinction between Silky being racist and her comments which were, in fact, racist.. "It's just something that should be addressed because again we lack enough asian awareness to realize just saying Japanese words to a Vietnamese person isn't funny."
Silky responded by saying that if Plastique had a problem, Plastique should be the one to say something.
\u201c@shotwithsoju If she felt some type of way, she could have said something then or now. She laughed and carried on. What you won\u2019t do is use me for likes and views. Stop creating a whole new narrative.\u201d— Silky \u201cCancel Student Loans\u201d Ganache (@Silky \u201cCancel Student Loans\u201d Ganache) 1556188157
Silky ended the conversation by saying that the two would have a conversation about it at the reunion.
\u201c@shotwithsoju @plastiquetiara You know what. No worries. This can be a topic at the reunion.\u201d— Silky \u201cCancel Student Loans\u201d Ganache (@Silky \u201cCancel Student Loans\u201d Ganache) 1556188157
Because the clip of the incident was released as a preview prior to Thursday's episode, Plastique already weighed in on the exchange, asking fans not to throw hate at Silky for what she said.
"Nobody deserves to be hated," Plastique said. "We can all take this as a learning experience and grow."
\u201cNobody deserves to be hated. We can all take this as a learning experience and grow.\u201d— Plastique Tiara (@Plastique Tiara) 1556216429
Silky has been in hot water for discriminatory comments lobbed at her fellow queens. In March, at an appearance at Roscoe's in Chicago, she made a comment about fellow queen Mercedes Iman Diamond, who is Muslim, that many thought equated her to being a terrorist.
"Behind the scenes, making the promo shoot, I said this is going to be the shadiest season, the fakest season," Silky told the crowd. "Then Mercedes walked up and I said, 'This season's going to blow up'!"
Mercedes addressed the Islamophobia she experienced in her life -- not from Silky -- during an episode that aired later in March.
Plastique's Vietnamese heritage came up again later in the episode when Michelle Visage criticized her for using what she felt was an Asian stereotype in her character during the weekly maxi challenge. When Plastique tried to respond to Visage, she said that she should have "Asian pride" and not be an Asian stereotype, prompting some on social media to point out that Visage should not lump all Asian people under "Asian pride" or, as a white person, tell an Asian person how to display their heritage.
\u201cCRAFTING SO MUCH OF THE SHOW TO PLAY ON ASIAN STEREOTYPES, THEN ALLOWING SILKY\u2019S RACISM AGAINST ASIANS AND THEN DELEGITIMISING PLASTIQUE\u2019S \u2018ASIANNESS\u2019 AND THEN MICHELLE TO LECTURE AN ASIAN ABOUT WHAT ASIAN PRIDE IS... SO DONE\u201d— the obviously attractive radam ridwan (@the obviously attractive radam ridwan) 1556278585
RELATED | Lizzo Just Dropped a Music Video with All Your Favorite Drag Queens
Sexy MAGA: Viral post saying Republicans 'have two daddies now' gets a rise from the right